In order for us to have a productive critique session the following process rules will be followed:
The author of the image being evaluated will be kept anonymous during the critique/scoring process.
The score of the image will not be revealed if the author indicated, when submitting the image, he/she did not want it scored when the image was submitted.
The critique of the image will be provided by one of the three judges. The designated judge will provide verbal constructive feedback in the form of positive attributes and areas that could be improved. At the completion of the critique, the judge will ask if the author has any questions. At this point the author of the image can ask any questions.
No audience participation will be allowed during the process.
The judges will have access to view and score the image prior to the meeting so this process will be completed autonomously of the critique.